column.gif (9122 bytes)

Loud Thinking
Ignoble Intentions



By Abhijit Dasgupta

boxcol.gif (494 bytes)

usm-red.gif (844 bytes)Economist Column
Insurance Bill to woo foreign investor
usm-red.gif (844 bytes)1999
A possible turning point in Indian Politics
usm-red.gif (844 bytes)Ringside View
To everybody's amusement, VHP finds motives on Amarty's Noble
usm-red.gif (844 bytes)Loud Thinking
Ignoble Intentions

Percy Bysheey Shelley was not quite off the mark when he spoke of a ``method in madness;'' the poet could not have, for purely historical reasons, been aware of a party called the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) which has lately come up in India in a big way, but what he had said more than 150 years back seems to aptly qualify this religious party which is an ally of the political BJP, now ruling the country There is a system by which the BJP-VHP-RSS nexus is trying to wreck this country and if that comes about through actions and utterances which are necessarily taken to be the product of a lunatic mind, then at least the Sangh Parivar is not complaining. The means, whatever they may be, always justifies the end. The end is to create a fascist state; the means, obviously in line with the goal, has to be through the nonsensical and unintelligible route.

But this is to take nothing away from the siege within; the danger lurking in the thesis which is being propagated by the Sangh Parivar as the magic formula for India's survival. Only a week back, the VHP chief, Ashoke Singhal, addressing a meeting at Jaipur in Rajasthan said that the Nobel Prize for Prof Amartya Sen was part of a wider plan to spread Chrisitianity in the country. If the comment can be simply treated as the remark of a silly mind, unread in the factors that govern the educated world, then nothing more should be read into it other than a mere and cursory stifled smirk at its audacity.The unfortunate part of the matter is that it is not so;Singhal happens to be the chief of a major force of this country and one which shares much of its philosophy with the ruling party at the Centre. Prof Sen is a national asset, a source of much of our recent glory and pride; to talk of him in such terms publicly requires censure from all right-thinking people and quarters.

The BJP naturally has been embarrassed but there has been no public apology from the men in power to that man who has been thus insulted. Instead, Singhal has been pressurised to tone down with his remark with a qualification that the nation indeed remains proud of the Nobel Laureate and the finance minister, Yashwant Sinha, has been rushed to consult Prof Sen on matters economic. The good professor may be still inclined to listen to these jokers and give them a word of two of advice on policy and the finance minister may be given his share of place in the shadows for having been the unfortunate one handpicked by his bosses to go and listen to sound economic sermons, but the fact remains that Singhal seems to be unrepentant. He has not said sorry in so many words and the various other developments in the country, the Gujarat riots , for example, and the continued attacks on Christians in that state by the Sangh Parivar seem to be orchestrated towards a definite end. Bengal's chief minister, Jyoti Basu, has rightly said that the ``siege has begun'' and that the people who could sully the name of someone like Prof Sen could not only be condemned for such utterances but that they would remain ``barabarians'' all the same. Nothing could have been more correctly put. If the hallmark of civilization has always been the right to live and the duty to protect, then members of the Sangh Parivar at least do not qualify as denizens of any civilised society. If they could travel well back in time, they would have been happy and definitely felt the comforts of being at home with the likes of Attila the Hun or Alaric the Goth.

There is indeed a method in this madness. Singhal is nobody's fool. Neither is the RSS strongman, Kushabhau Thakre, who is now the national president of the BJP. The Bajrang Dal is their tool as the name itself suggests; we are told that most Dal activists, with the song of the monkey god on their lips, are highly qualified musclemen up to monkey tricks for the better part of the day. They have indulged in hooliganism in the past: artist M.F. Husain would vouch for that. In Gujarat, they have let loose a series of attacks on the Christian community, part of which will surely be confined to the garbage of the history bin later by sane people.

Questions, however, cannot be avoided; why Christians and why now? Why Prof Sen and why the Nobel Prize? The answer may not be hard to find. The Sangh Parivar is realising slowly that all its grand talk of ``good governance'' is fast becoming a myth. Atal Behari Vajpayee himself is cornered and the slogan of ``able PM, stable India'' is now a phrase which will soon not be uttered in any BJP manifesto in the future. L.K.Advani, with his Hindutva plank, is waiting in the wings. The country, as everybody is slowly comprehending, cannot be run by this government and elections could be a distinct possibility soon. The Sangh Parivar is thus a concerned pack now; it does not have a poll plank with which it can ride Advani to power. The Muslim-Ayodhya card and the questions of appeasement and Kashmir and infiltration seem to have been answered by the people themselves. The mother of all mosques lies in the dust at Ayodhya. The Christians are, by nature, a soft target. They are not easily roused but can bring international focus; not coincidentally again, Singhal, while making that blasphemous remark against Prof Sen, had also dragged in the name of another venerable Nobel Laureate of this country known as Mother Teresa. The idea thus is now to bring to the fore rabid Hinduism and the Hindutva plank once again; if out of sheer poll necessity, a few thousand Christians are butchered and hundreds of churches are razed to the ground, that does not send any tremor down the spines of those who believe that it is only their brand of Hinduism which can save this nation. Religion, sadly, is opium; it is sadder still it has been turned into a major election exercise.

Whoever chooses not to see the method in this madness is soon to be corrected about the sort of paradise that he is living in. The siege has begun. In right earnest.





search2.gif (14394 bytes)                            
Search Site                           

Ganashakti Newsmagazine
74A Acharya Jagadish Chandra Bose Road
Kolkata,India 700016

email: mail@ganashakti.co.in
Tel: 91-33-2227-8950 Fax: 91-33-2227-6263/8090

©Ganashakti, Reproduction in any form without permission prohibited

lo.gif (5609 bytes)

Home Week Archive Portal Feedback
Content Editorial Headline World Nation Bengal Column Feature

Contact Us
Site Designed and Hosted by Arijit Upadhyay