column.gif (9122 bytes)

critic.gif (527 bytes)Economist’s Column
Development And Human Rights The Inherent Interdependencies

boxcol.gif (494 bytes)

usm-red.gif (844 bytes)Economist Column
D
evelopement & human rights, the inherent inter-dependencies

Nita Mitra (Reader in Economics University of Calcutta)

The body of literature on human rights that have evolved over the years is not only rich but also very extensive. The crusaders who have sought to highlight the human rights issue, have touched upon diverse areas ranging from social tyranny, terrorism & counter state terrorism to combat violation of human rights, the abuse of human rights on the part of security forces, the misuse of intelligence services for surveillance of political opponents, continued ghettoisation of ecological space and so on.

Off late the literature on development has brought in the human rights issue. The contribution of Amartya Sen, among others, marks a radical departure from earlier approaches. One finds, in his framework of analysis, the human rights issue being related to a particular conceptualisation of development i.e., - development as FREEDOM. When freedom is acknowledged to be the principal end of development, then various kinds of freedoms such as political, social and so on. Where liberty of political participation as also of dissent become part and parcel of the development process become important. So such a framework, in corporate freedoms and rights also as being effective in enhancing economic progress.

The vector of attributes of development in terms of several kinds of freedoms and their interlinkages, in effect helps one to overcome the limitations of the narrower views of development that have tended to identify it with growth of gross national product or with rise in personal incomes and so on. Growth is of course an important means of expanding freedoms enjoyed by members of the society. But, freedom also depend on such other determinants as social and economic arrangements such as facilities for education or health as well as political and civil rights or the liberty to participate in public discussions a security.

Sen’s categorisation of rights has also enlarged the area of discourse on the human rights issue, removing much of the unfusion that exists in our mindset. Rights as legal entity with instrumental rather than any intrinsic value and right having intrinsic value in terms of value of right-fulfillment and disvalue of right-violation are two different categories. It is this latter category of rights which eventually lead towards such relevant inter relationships between rights, liberties and real opportunities. There inter linkages or inter dependencies help one to understand why human right within the core of the development process.

Such a framework may be suitable for identifying the major sources of "unfreedom" in terms of i) poverty ii) of tyranny iii) of poor economic opportunities iv) of systematic social deprivation v) of absence of basic public facilities vi) of intolerance vii) of over activity of repressive states and so on. In fact, it is these very objectives that have come to be included within the national and international human rights codes.

The real danger, perhaps relates to the globalisation process and the inherent progress towards the Hegelian absolute freedom of a "global citizen" called the transnational and the possibilities of directing or sucking up of funds, at its sole discretion. These apart, its freedom to distort international trade laws, to dominate the world economy, may not at all reduce or help remove, the major sources of "unfreedom" that exist in many parts of the world. Does not one observe the prospects of multi polar globalisation dimmed by the domination of hegemony, over the world economic and political order? Under such circumstances, until an alternative definition of internationalism can be arrived at the process of globalisation may drive a wedge between development and human rights. The accentuates of global inequalities in such a bi-polar world may enhance economic unfreedom which in turn may breed social and political unfreedom, thwarting the process of development itself. It is important to understand the basic interdependencies and to realise that simultaneous deprivations within the development process itself may compound the overall failures on the human rights front also. Most critics would not subscribe to the viewpoint that globalisation would further the cause of human rights given such pervasive interdependencies.





search2.gif (14394 bytes)                            
Search Site                           

Ganashakti Newsmagazine
74A Acharya Jagadish Chandra Bose Road
Kolkata,India 700016

email: mail@ganashakti.co.in
Tel: 91-33-2227-8950 Fax: 91-33-2227-6263/8090

©Ganashakti, Reproduction in any form without permission prohibited

lo.gif (5609 bytes)

Home Week Archive Portal Feedback
Content Editorial Headline World Nation Bengal Column Feature

Contact Us
Site Designed and Hosted by Arijit Upadhyay